UKSC/2026/0111

•

Hamer (Appellant) v Levy (Respondent)

Case summary


Case ID

UKSC/2026/0111

Parties

Appellant(s)

Linda Peggy Hamer

Respondent(s)

Hesther Levy

Issue

Did the Respondent provide the Appellant with the information required by Section 213(5) of the Housing Act 2004 in a form “substantially to the same effect” as the prescribed form?

Facts

In October 2019, the Respondent granted the Appellant an assured shorthold tenancy of a property in Devon. In connection with the payment of a tenancy deposit, the Respondent sent the Appellant certain prescribed information in accordance with the statutory requirements. In April 2024, the Respondent’s solicitors sent a letter notifying the Appellant that the Respondent sought possession of the property, and subsequently served the Appellant with a section 21 notice. The Appellant filed a defence, alleging that the prescribed information previously sent by the Respondent contained several technical deficiencies, including errors in the Respondent’s contact address and telephone number. In August 2024, the district judge affirmed the validity of the notice and ordered the Appellant to give possession of the property to the Respondent. The Appellant filed a notice of appeal against the possession order, which was stayed pending determination of the appeal. In November 2024, the circuit judge struck out the Appellant’s appeal as having no real prospect of success. The Appellant appealed to the High Court, where Pepperall J struck out her appeal and lifted the stay on the execution of the warrant of possession, on the grounds that the proposed appeal should have been made to the Court of Appeal. In December 2025, the Appellant filed a notice of appeal to the Court of Appeal. She advanced 16 grounds of appeal, alleging procedural unfairness in the hearing before the district judge and arguing that service of the section 21 notice was invalidated by the various errors in the prescribed information. In its judgment of 22 May 2026, the Court of Appeal expressed concerns with the procedural fairness of the hearing before the district judge and found the circuit judge’s decision to strike out the appeal to be procedurally flawed. Nonetheless, the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, finding that (a) the errors in the prescribed information were of no material consequence and (b) the information provided to the Appellant by the Respondent’s solicitors’ April 2024 letter (which referenced the prescribed information contained in the tenancy agreement) was in a form “substantially to the same effect” as the prescribed statutory requirements, in accordance with Section 213(6) of the Housing Act 2004. The Appellant now appeals to the Supreme Court.

Date of issue

28 July 2026

Case origin

PTA

Permission to Appeal


Justices

Permission to Appeal decision date

28 July 2026

Permission to Appeal decision

Refused

Previous proceedings

Back to top

Sign up for updates about this case

Sign up to receive email alerts when this case is updated.