Case details

O'Brien (Appellant) v Ministry of Justice (Respondent)

Case ID: UKSC 2015/0248

Case summary

Issue

Where a pension is calculable by reference to service, whether the period of service prior the coming into effect of the relevant directive should be taken into account in calculating the amount of pension to be paid.

Facts

Mr O’Brien was appointed as a Recorder sitting part-time on the Western Circuit on 1 March 1978, an office he held until 31 March 2005. He is entitled to a pension by virtue of the Part Time Workers Directive (97/81/EC) which the United Kingdom was required to transpose into domestic law by 7 April 2000. Mr O’Brien launched a claim in the Employment Tribunal, contending that he was entitled to have his service prior to 7 April 2000 taken into account in the calculation of the amount of his pension. The Employment Tribunal issued a decision in Mr O’Brien’s favour on this issue; on appeal, the Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the Ministry of Justice’s appeal; and the Court of Appeal agreed with the Employment Appeal Tribunal and dismissed Mr O’Brien’s appeal. Mr O’Brien now appeals to the Supreme Court on this issue.

Mr O’Brien, together with the Miller appellants, contended in a separate appeal that their claims of unlawful discrimination were not made out of time. The Court of Appeal held that, in view of its decision in the first O’Brien appeal, the claims were made out of time. The appellants appeal to the Supreme Court on this issue.

Judgment appealed

[2015] EWCA Civ 1000

Parties

Appellants

Dermod O'Brien

Respondent

Ministry of Justice

Permission to Appeal Hearing

Justices

Lady Hale, Lord Reed, Lord Carnwath

Hearing start date

07 Jul 2016

Hearing finish date

07 Jul 2016

Appeal

Justices

Lady Hale, Lord Kerr, Lord Reed, Lord Carnwath, Lord Hughes

Hearing start date

08 Mar 2017

Hearing finish date

09 Mar 2017

Watch Permission to Appeal hearing
07 Jul 2016 Morning session
Watch hearing
08 Mar 2017 Morning session Afternoon session
09 Mar 2017 Morning session Afternoon session